Skip to content


finding the best Health Insurance, Employee Benefits, and Medicare Supplement plans for your lifestyle, needs, and budget for more than 30 years.

Get Your Personalized Quote!

Interested?  Make an appointment.

Insurance Offerings

We shop for the best health insurance deals EVERY YEAR.




Why Choose Us?

Exceptional service and support.

We are here for you at every step

We are different from other agencies – we specialize in small group insurance, employee benefits, Medicare, and individual coverage. This means that our client relationships are of the utmost importance to us. With Comprehensive Assurance, you’re never just a statistic or an account number to us. We treat each and every one of our clients as though they are our only client.

Dependable Customer Service

Fair and Honest Assessments

Fair and Honest Assessments

You'll never find us pushing you into coverage that isn't right for you - we make our money via commission from multiple sources (and we don't get more money for selling more features), so we'll never favor one provider over another or give you unreliable information in favor of a sale.

A Wide Range of Providers to Choose From

A Wide Range of Providers to Choose From

We work with several major Pittsburgh and Western PA area health care providers to ensure the best range of plans for our clients, including Highmark, UPMC, Coventry, Aetna, Cigna, Humana, Silver Scripts, and others.

Experience You Can Trust

Experience You Can Trust

Our founder, Alfred Papa, actually wrote the very first PPO plan used for insurance in Pennsylvania. Our company has since continued the trend of setting new standards. We were some of the first brokers in the area to concentrate on smaller groups - often as small as 20 people.

We Are Not Incentivized to Sell

We Are Not Incentivized to Sell

Our services come at no cost to you. We learn your needs and find the best possible plans from our network of providers. A job well-done for us means matching you with the most satisfactory coverage.